Alone Show Season 5 Contestants?

Awwww yeah, who is excited for Season 5 of History Channel’s Alone Show?! Season 4 wrapped up just last week and at the end of the reunion episode, they played a brief trailer for season 5. I haven’t seen that trailer pop up anywhere online, but if you have on-demand set up for Alone, or stream the show, check out the end of the special episode called “Tales from the Island”.  If I can get my hands on a link I will update this post. Anywho, Season 5 looks to be a sort of “redemption season” where they’re bringing back select contestants that didn’t win from all of the previous Alone seasons so far.

In the trailer, there were audio clips of 9 contestants voices (although there will be 10 contestants most likely) that played with some images of scenery from a completely new location. I stream the show online, so my husband and I were able to pause and replay the trailer a few times after it aired to listen closely to the voices. I think we’ve identified most of the contestant’s voices that were in the trailer! Check out who we think might be on the next season.

The list is in the order that the voices played in the trailer. Remember, these are just guesses. Please comment below if you think I’ve guessed wrong! I’d love to know who everyone thinks is coming back! 🙂 I’ve got a couple with question marks next to their name because I’m not 100% sure it’s them, but I think we’ve gotten really close.

UPDATE: Here is a link to the audio file if you wish to listen for yourself! Thank you to Bonkerz on Bushcraft USA for posting this. 🙂

  1. Alex Ribar? – Season 4


  2. Brad RichardsonSeason 4

  3. Brody WilkesSeason 4

  4. Dustin FeherSeason 1

  5. Megan Hanacek – Season 3

  6. Randy Champagne? – Season 2

  7. Jose Martinez AmoedoSeason 2

  8. Sam LarsonSeason 1

  9. Larry RobertsSeason 2 


Okay! that’s what I’m guessing! I cannot wait to see who comes back. The different location looks amazing, and I’d love to see how people’s strategies change and adapt. What do you think?



  1. tom

    Since they’re bringing back past survivalists who quit,I won’t be watching. There’s way too many people vying for the few coveted spots to bring back past quiters.

    1. Mick Badgero

      Tom, I agree with you that they shouldn’t be using a crew from old shows. But I will still watch the show. I can still learn a few things from them that I can use if I ever get on the show myself.

    2. Seriously

      THat is why I am picking someone from season 3 I had to miss it. So I went through the list
      And I like Dan Wowak, but if you don’t like it because you quit ! It depends on the reason..some have to leave to get a winner,, so it all depends

  2. Adam

    They reached out to Joe Robinet from season 1 but it fell through. Too bad. Joe is a beast.

  3. Micky Badgero

    New location would be better with new contestants. These folks have already had a chance, and there are thousands of others who would like a chance. I would love to be on the show. That said, these would be my picks for previous cast members:

    From season 1: Sam Larson, Mitch Mitchell, Lucas Miller

    From season 2: Larry Roberts, Jose Martinez Amoedo, Nicole Apelian

    From season 3: Carleigh Fairchild, Megan Hanacek, Dave Nessia, Callie North

    These folks have proven themselves.

    Harder to pick from season 4. Maybe Sam Brockdorff and Dave Whipple. How can they give someone who didn’t make it two weeks a second chance?

  4. Jason

    Love the series, can’t wait for Season 5. If they do another hike, it seems like a machete could make all the difference. As a former surveyor, without trails you almost have to have one.

  5. Marriah

    Just in case nobody else has noticed, Callie has ghosted on social media and her shop website is down. #teamcallie

    1. Miranda

      She still posts almost daily on Instagram.

      I do wish that she would be one of the new contestants, though! I was so bummed when she tapped out.

  6. Bonkerz

    I really like the whole redemption idea and will be looking forward to season 5. I’ve listened to that preview audio and I’m with you on Megan, Jose, Sam and Larry. Can’t say about the others.

    1. shhhh......

      Heres an insider tip: the voices you hear on the preview are not necessarily who will be on this next season. We are not sure why they included peoples voices who aren’t on it but there you go….Some of the folks on your list will be there this new season….but there are a few you need to reconsider.


Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: